Replication Study Manuscript Evaluation Form

Motivation for replication cleary stated and convincing:
N/A - Not ApplicableStrongly DisagreeModerately DisagreeAgreeModerately AgreeStrongly Agree

Study is consistent with replicated research:

Adequately compares current results to prior results:

Extends the previous study:

Analysis of extension is appropriate for research question:

Conclusions are appropriate given the result:

Paper would be of interest to readership:

Manuscript is well written:


If you comments for the editors, please enter them below. These comments will not be seen by the author.

Authors will not receive a copy of this form.

Please provide written comments to the authors in Word or PDF by attaching the file using the button below. Include the manuscript title and number on the review comments. Do not indicate your recommendation in the author's review comments.

When you click submit below, your submission will be submitted to the journal editor and you will receive a copy of the email.